Hi Emma,
Sorry to hear youre Groodle chewed through this toy.
However this is one of the softer rubber toys not in the 'STAFFY APPROVED' power chewer section of our webiste. This toy is more for light chewers, I do have stronger options that would be more suitable, similar to the Harold toy you also purchased. How is that one holding up? Im sure it would be lasting.
Im happy to offer you a store credit for the missunderstanding so you can get another stronger instead! Send me an email to redeem the credit.
Kind regards, Luke from Ace Dog Supplies. :)